Either assessment is presumed correct, and the burden is on you to show it is wrong (R1210.300, P520). Below 5.00 reported MPG the 20% cut gives the lower MPG; above 5.00 the 4.00 floor does. IFTA Procedures Manual P570.100; IFTA Articles of Agreement R1210.
Two kinds of assessment
The IFTA rules use two tools when the base jurisdiction cannot rely on what you reported. The IFTA Articles of Agreement R1210 covers a licensee who fails to file a return when due, fails to make records available on written request, or “fails to maintain records from which the licensee's true liability may be determined”. In those cases the base jurisdiction must act on the best information available to it: it determines your tax for each jurisdiction, revokes or suspends your license, or both (R1210.200).
The IFTA Procedures Manual P570 is the formula used in an audit when records fall short. It applies when the base jurisdiction finds that your records, for the fleet as a whole, do not meet the adequacy test in P530, or when you produce no records after a written demand. Both lead to the same place: more tax, plus penalty and interest, and a presumption that the assessment is right.
The P570 formula
P570.100 says the base jurisdiction “shall impose an additional assessment” by one of these methods:
| Method | Section | What changes |
|---|---|---|
| Reduce fleet MPG to 4.00 (1.70 kilometers per liter) | P570.100.005 | Fuel used is recomputed at 4.00 MPG |
| Reduce the average fuel consumption factor (MPG, KPL, MPGe or any other distance per unit of fuel) by 20 percent | P570.100.010 | Fuel used rises by a quarter (distance divided by 80 percent of the factor) |
| For jurisdictions that tax fuel by applying a rate to distance, increase jurisdiction distance by 20 percent | P570.100.015 | Only that jurisdiction's distance; total distance does not change |
The words come straight from the manual: “reducing the licensee's reported fleet MPG to 4.00 or 1.70 KPL”, or reducing the reported factor by 20 percent. For distance-taxed fuels, P570.100.015 adds that “The jurisdictional distance increase shall not affect total distance”.
The current wording is new. Ballot 5-2024 extended the factor to any measure of distance per unit of fuel, effective January 1, 2026, so it reaches electric and other alternative fuel vehicles. Ballot 3-2025 changed "adjusting" to "reducing", set the 20 percent cut and added the distance rule, also effective January 1, 2026 (P570 commentary). Ballot 3-2025 failed at the 2025 Annual Business Meeting and then passed in the vote that ended December 18, 2025 (IFTA, Inc. ballots page).
P570 joins the methods with "or" and does not say how the base jurisdiction chooses between them. Expect the auditor to explain the choice in the audit report, which must include an explanation of distance and fuel adjustments and the auditor's evaluation of the adequacy of records (IFTA Audit Manual A460.500).
A worked example
This arithmetic shows how the formula moves the numbers. It uses gallons only, with no tax rates; the real assessment applies each jurisdiction's rate for the quarter, plus penalty and interest.
A fleet reports 120,000 total miles and 20,000 gallons for a quarter, a fleet average of 6.00 MPG. It reports 30,000 taxable miles in one jurisdiction, so that jurisdiction's taxable gallons are 30,000 divided by 6.00, or 5,000.
| As reported | Factor cut 20% (P570.100.010) | 4.00 MPG (P570.100.005) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fleet MPG | 6.00 | 4.80 | 4.00 |
| Total fuel implied (120,000 miles) | 20,000 gallons | 25,000 gallons | 30,000 gallons |
| Taxable gallons in the 30,000-mile jurisdiction | 5,000 | 6,250 | 7,500 |
| Increase in that jurisdiction | 1,250 gallons (25%) | 2,500 gallons (50%) |
The tax-paid gallons you bought in each jurisdiction do not change, so the whole increase becomes net taxable fuel. If reported MPG is below 5.00, the 20 percent cut produces the lower MPG; above 5.00, the 4.00 floor does.
One vehicle versus the whole fleet
P570 is about the fleet as a whole. When only some vehicles have bad records, the IFTA Audit Manual A350 works vehicle by vehicle. For specific vehicles whose records are substantially impaired or missing, the auditor may adjust fuel and distance based on your prior experience, carriers with similar operations, similar vehicles in your fleet, industry averages, records from fuel distributors or other third parties, or other pertinent information (A350.200). Only if those fail to support an adjustment may the jurisdiction, for those vehicles, cut the factor by 20 percent, set MPG to 4.00 (KPL 1.7), or raise distance in distance-taxed jurisdictions by 20 percent (A350.300).
When the fleet's records are adequate, the auditor can still adjust your reported MPG based on what the records show (A350.100). A good records system limits the damage to the vehicles that actually had problems.
Tax-paid credits and total fuel
An inadequate-records assessment does not restore credits you cannot document. P570.200 keeps the base jurisdiction's power to disallow tax-paid credit for fuel purchases that are not properly documented, and Consensus Board Interpretation 1-2026 (ratified August 2026 as commentary to P550.220 and P570.200) says P570.200 does not override the receipt rules in P550.220. Missing receipts and missing distance records are two separate problems with two separate costs. The receipt side is on IFTA fuel receipts.
On the other side, the auditor cannot cut the fuel you reported just because receipts are missing. A360 says “The total fuel reported by a licensee shall only be reduced when there is clear proof, based on the records provided by the licensee, to support such a reduction”.
Estimated assessments for unfiled returns
If you do not file, the base jurisdiction does not wait for an audit. Under R1210, it determines your liability for each jurisdiction from the best information available, may revoke or suspend your license, and serves the assessment after adding the appropriate penalties and interest (R1210.300). For assessments based on missing records, it “must issue a written request for records giving the licensee thirty (30) days to provide the records” or issue a notice of insufficient records (R1210.200).
Carriers who should have been licensed but were not are covered too. R305 says that if a jurisdiction determines a person required to be licensed failed to do so, it is “specifically authorized to assess and collect any and all fuel taxes due from such person for all member jurisdictions”. See who needs an IFTA license.
The cleanest way out of an estimated assessment for an unfiled quarter is to file the return with real numbers, even a zero return if you did not operate. Penalty and interest still apply to a late return (see IFTA penalties and interest).
How base jurisdictions describe it
Base jurisdictions repeat the rule in their own guides. Indiana's Fuel Tax Account Quick Reference Guide (June 2026) says non-filers are assessed tax plus penalties and interest, that assessments use the best information available including past filing history, and that “In the absence of adequate records, fuel consumption and miles traveled will be determined using a standard of four miles per gallon or a 20% reduction in reported average fuel consumption factor”. Idaho's IFTA handbook says an inadequate records assessment “could mean that your IFTA fleet MPG is reduced by as much as 20 percent, or to 4.00”. North Carolina's 2026 compliance manual says a proposed assessment is presumed correct, with the burden of proof on the licensee. The rule is the same across members; the forms and appeal steps are each base jurisdiction's own.
How IRP handles missing records
IRP uses a flat percentage instead of a fuel formula. Under IRP Plan Section 1015, if your records are inadequate, or you produce none within 30 calendar days of a written request, the base jurisdiction imposes an assessment of “twenty percent of the Apportionable Fees paid” for the registration year, 50 percent for a second offense and 100 percent for a third. The same missing trip records can therefore cost you under both programs. See IRP records and audits.
How to challenge an assessment
The burden is yours. R1210.300 says an assessment made under it is presumed correct, and you must show “by a fair preponderance of evidence that the assessment is erroneous or excessive”. In an audit, P520 puts the burden on you as well.
- Answer the written request. You have 30 days under R1210.200. Produce whatever you have, organized by quarter and vehicle, rather than nothing.
- Rebuild what you can. A350.200 lets the auditor use records from fuel distributors or other third parties and other pertinent information, so gather what exists: fuel card company listings, maintenance records with odometer readings, bills of lading and dispatch records.
- Ask for the schedules. R1370.300 entitles you to the schedules and worksheets behind audit findings.
- Appeal on time. You have at least 30 calendar days from notice of audit findings to file a written appeal with your base jurisdiction (R1390); unfiled-return assessments follow the base jurisdiction's procedures under R1400.
- Ask about penalty relief. The base jurisdiction may waive penalties for reasonable cause (R1260.100). The tax itself is not waived.
This page is general information about the IFTA rules, not legal or tax advice. For a large assessment, consider a tax professional familiar with your base jurisdiction's procedures.
Questions filers ask
What MPG does IFTA use if I have no records?
P570 reduces your reported fleet MPG to 4.00 (1.70 KPL), or reduces your reported consumption factor by 20 percent. For jurisdictions that tax by distance, jurisdiction distance is increased by 20 percent instead.
Which method will my base jurisdiction use, 4.00 MPG or 20 percent?
P570 lists both and does not say how to choose. The audit report must explain the adjustments, so ask the auditor which was used and why.
Can the auditor estimate only for the trucks with missing records?
Yes. A350.200 and A350.300 let the auditor adjust specific vehicles based on other evidence, and use the 20 percent cut or 4.00 MPG for those vehicles only if that evidence fails.
I never filed some quarters. What happens?
The base jurisdiction determines your tax from the best information available, adds penalty and interest, and may revoke or suspend your license (R1210). Filing the returns with actual figures is the usual way to replace an estimate.
How long do I have to produce records after a request?
R1210.200 requires a written request giving you 30 days to provide records, or the jurisdiction issues a notice of insufficient records.
Is an assessment the same as a penalty?
No. The assessment is tax. The IFTA penalty of $50 or 10 percent and interest are added on top (R1210.300, R1220, R1230).