- Where
- Weigh stations, inspection stations, rest areas, any marked site on a public highway
- No violation
- Letter 3143
- Violation
- Form 886-A, then Letter 3145 with the penalty package
- Appeal window
- Form 12009 within 30 days
- Reasonable cause
- Not available for IRC 6715IRC 6715Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII
Inspections and the 2026 relief
The penalty itself is on dyed diesel rules and penalties: the greater of $1,000 or $10 a gallon, plus the back-up tax, under IRC 6715IRC 6715Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII. This page covers the process that leads to it, from the IRS's inspection and case manuals (IRM 4.24.15 and 4.24.16).
For now the inspections are paused. In its fall 2026 relief, the IRS said “no federal inspections of on-road dyed fuel usage will occur” during the relief period, which it said runs through December 31, 2026 (IR-2026-122). From January 1, 2027, the normal process below applies again, and the IRS has said it is weighing a grace period for dye left in tanks. We checked again on November 21, 2026: the IRS's November news releases (IR-2026-130 to IR-2026-143), its statements page and the Internal Revenue Bulletins through 2026-48 carry nothing that ends, extends or changes the pause, and the IR-2026-122 release reads as issued. Check the IRS newsroom again before January 1.
Where the IRS inspects
The IRS can inspect at a long list of places: “Designated inspection sites are all state highway inspection stations, weigh stations, agricultural inspection stations, mobile stations, construction sites, parks, rest areas, any points on a public highway or any other locations as designated by the Commissioner to be used as a fuel inspection site.” (IRM 4.24.15.2.1.3(1)). The site is marked with an "IRS Fuel Inspection Site" sign (IRM 4.24.15.2.1.3(2)), and on a highway “Law enforcement personnel must be present and control traffic flow.” (IRM 4.24.15.6(3)).
Part of the purpose is education. The IRM lists three goals for these stops, including to “Educate drivers of diesel vehicles about dyed fuel laws and provide Publication 4941, Trucker Bulletin, as warranted.” (IRM 4.24.15.6(1)).
At the truck
The officer must identify themselves and give the driver Notice 916, Taxable Fuel Inspection Notice, before inspecting (IRM 4.24.15.6.1(4)), then screens the fuel in the propulsion tank (IRM 4.24.15.6.1(7)).
IRM 4.24.15.2.1.3(1), 4.24.15.6(3) and 4.24.15.6.1(4), (8), (9) and (12).
Clean tank. “If no dyed fuel is present and the fuel appears normal, employee will secure only the tag and state information and then release the driver.” (IRM 4.24.15.6.1(8)). For an on-road stop with no violation, the IRM says employees should issue Letter 3143, Non-violation Results of Inspection (IRM 4.24.16.2.2(2)).
Dyed fuel. “If dyed fuel is present, employee will inform the driver, issue Publication 1, and secure a "usage" sample.” (IRM 4.24.15.6.1(9)). The officer then records the driver's and company's names, addresses and phone numbers, the driver's position and license, the company's EIN, the vehicle, the tank capacity and estimated fuel, and any other fuel tanks on the truck (IRM 4.24.15.6.1(10)), and asks who fueled the truck, when, where, whether the company has a yard tank and how it fuels its trucks (IRM 4.24.15.6.1(11)). Drivers should answer accurately and refer questions about the company's fueling to whoever handles fuel.
The follow-up at your yard
A roadside finding rarely ends at the roadside. The officer “will immediately "follow the fuel" when possible and conduct follow-up inspections to determine the extent of the non-compliance” (IRM 4.24.15.6.1(12)). At a yard, the officer presents credentials, gives you Notice 916 and Pub. 1, and reviews your business, fuel types, number of diesel trucks, tank locations and suppliers, delivery records and fueling practice (IRM 4.24.15.7.1(1) and (2)). A dyed reading in a truck leads to samples from each propulsion tank and from the storage tank that supplied it (IRM 4.24.15.7.1(3)).
The yard tank is where the gallons add up. Under IRM 4.24.15.7.1(5), the gallons held for a taxable use are figured from the evidence you give about past and current use of the dyed fuel, and, citing a court decision, “in the absence of credible evidence to the contrary, all dyed fuel held in the storage tank may be presumed to be involved in the violation” (IRM 4.24.15.7.1(5), first bullet). Records of what the tank fuels (a reefer, farm equipment, a generator) are your evidence.
Refusing an inspection
The rules differ by place. At a designated site on the road, the officer first asks the driver's consent, and if it is refused the officer stops and may seek a writ of entry (IRM 4.24.15.2.1.3(4) and (6)); the IRM says a penalty under IRC 6717IRC 6717Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII, the refusal penalty, “generally does not apply at these sites.” (IRM 4.24.15.2.1.3(7)). One reason: “Fuel in the propulsion tank of a vehicle is not considered "fuel storage" for purposes of IRC 4083(d)IRC 4083Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII.” (IRM 4.24.15.2.1.1(1)). At a site you own or control, such as your yard and its tanks, refusing brings the IRC 6717IRC 6717Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII refusal penalty and a possible writ of entry (IRM 4.24.15.2.1.1(4)). This page describes the rules; it is not advice to refuse.
What the IRS needs to prove
The IRM sets two evidence rules. A sample is the norm, but a penalty “may be proposed without a fuel sample if employee visually detects that fuel in the vehicle or storage tank is dyed but is unable to obtain a sample using the approved sampling method” (IRM 4.24.15.7.2(3)). And talk alone is never enough: “Under no circumstances will employee propose a IRC 6715(a)(1)IRC 6715Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII or IRC 6715(a)(2)IRC 6715Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII based solely on testimony of the owner, an employee of the taxpayer or third party.” (IRM 4.24.15.7.2(4)).
The letters, in order
No reasonable cause exception applies to the IRC 6715IRC 6715Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII penalty. IRM 4.24.16.2.5(1) to (4), 4.24.16.3(3) and (5), 4.24.16.4(1) and (5); IRM 20.1.11.7.4(1).
| Step | What you receive | IRM |
|---|---|---|
| No violation, on the road | Letter 3143, Non-violation Results of Inspection | 4.24.16.2.2(2) |
| Violation found | Form 886-A, Explanation of Items, “at the time of the inspection or by the next business day” | 4.24.16.2.5(1) |
| Penalty approved | The penalty package: Letter 3145 (30-day letter), two copies of Form 12010 (Report of Proposed Penalty) and of Form 12009, Notice 1215 (What to Do if You Disagree with the Fuel Penalty), Pub. 1, and Notice 1416 if a state found it | 4.24.16.2.5(2) and (3) |
| Within 60 days of the package | A follow-up inspection | 4.24.16.2.5(4) |
| After an informal conference | Letter 3165 with the result | 4.24.16.3(9) |
| After a refund claim | Letter 5008, Fuel Penalty Claim | 4.24.16.4(5) |
The package goes out within 5 business days after the group manager approves the penalty (IRM 4.24.16.2.5(2)). The follow-up visit counts: “Employees must conduct a follow-up inspection within 60 days of the issuance of the penalty package”, and a violation found then “is treated as subsequent penalty for purposes of IRC 6715(b)(2)IRC 6715Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII” (IRM 4.24.16.2.5(4)), which raises the $1,000 floor. Drain and refill the truck and fix the yard practice at once.
Disputing the penalty
The 30 days run from the package: “within 30 days of receipt of the penalty package for an informal conference” (IRM 4.24.16.3(3)), on Form 12009, Request for an Informal Conference and Appeals Review. If the conference does not settle it, the case goes to the IRS Independent Office of Appeals unless you ask otherwise (same paragraph). Miss the 30 days and the route changes: “the taxpayer must pay the penalty and then file a claim for refund of the penalty paid” (IRM 4.24.16.3(5)), on Form 843 (IRM 4.24.16.4(1)).
What you cannot argue: “There is no reasonable cause exception to this penalty.” (IRM 20.1.11.7.4(1)). What Appeals does consider for the dyed fuel penalty includes whether the fuel was dyed, whether you knew or had reason to know, and whether “The IRS correctly determined the amount of fuel subject to the Dyed Fuel Penalty.” (IRM 8.7.10.13.3(3)(f)). After two earlier IRC 6715IRC 6715Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII penalties found by chemical analysis, a third can be appealed only for fraud or a mistake in the analysis or for a math error (IRC 6715(e)IRC 6715Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII; IRM 4.24.16.3(6)). taxproc.com explains Appeals conferences and refund claims for paid penalties in general.
State samples and state penalties
States run their own dyed fuel checks, and some share samples with the IRS. “IRS receives and tests fuel samples secured by state agencies, which perform fuel compliance activities.” (IRM 4.24.13.10(2)). The IRS may accept samples only from states it has an information-sharing agreement with (IRM 4.24.16.2.1(2)). Two limits protect you:
- “A state penalty does not automatically result in a federal penalty assessment.” (IRM 4.24.16.2.1(1)). The IRS weighs the state's information with everything else, including whether the sample is valid.
- “A person who refused to allow a state employee to conduct an inspection has not violated IRC 6717IRC 6717Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII.” (IRM 4.24.16.2.1(1), caution).
If the IRS does assess a federal penalty on a state's finding, you will not get Form 886-A for it; the package includes Notice 1416, State Penalty Notice, which “explains that the IRS is assessing a penalty for a violation based on information provided to the IRS from a state with an information-sharing memorandum of understanding (MOU)” (IRM 4.24.16.2.5(1), note). Federal sample results and penalty information are not shared with the states (IRM 4.24.13.10(3)). Federal and state fuel tax agencies also work together through the Joint Operations Center, which the IRM describes as “a partnership between federal and state motor fuel taxing authorities” (IRM 4.24.18.15(1)). Nothing in these IRM sections ties the federal process to your IFTA return; state dyed fuel penalties and IFTA reporting follow each state's own rules (see state relief in 2026).
What to keep ready
- Fuel receipts that show clear diesel for every truck, by date and unit, the same receipts your IFTA return relies on (IFTA fuel receipts; fuel receipt log).
- For any dyed fuel tank at the yard: delivery tickets and a log of what it fueled, so the gallons are not all presumed taxable.
- Separate, labeled tanks for reefers and equipment that may use dyed fuel. Pub. 510 says “Off-highway business use includes fuel used in a separate motor to operate special equipment, such as a refrigeration unit, pump, generator, or mixing unit.”
- A note in the truck with who to call about fuel questions, and a calendar reminder: 30 days from the penalty package.
Sources
- IRM 4.24.15, Fuel Compliance Inspection, Sampling and Shipping (January 29, 2025), irs.gov
- IRM 4.24.16, Fuel Compliance Report Writing, Case Processing and Appeals (June 5, 2023), irs.gov
- IRM 4.24.13.10 (September 9, 2024), irs.gov; IRM 4.24.18.15 (October 17, 2023), irs.gov
- IRM 20.1.11.7.4 (February 6, 2026), irs.gov; IRM 8.7.10.13.3 (December 13, 2024), irs.gov
- IRC 6715IRC 6715Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII and 6717; Pub. 510 (Rev. December 2025); IR-2026-122 (October 14, 2026)
The Internal Revenue Manual (IRM) is the IRS's own instruction book for its employees. It tells you what the IRS does with a return or a call, not what the law requires of you, and the IRS can change it at any time. This page is general information, not tax advice.
Questions filers ask
Can the IRS check my truck's fuel at a weigh station?
Yes. Weigh stations, state inspection stations, rest areas and any point on a public highway can be designated IRS fuel inspection sites, with law enforcement controlling traffic (IRM 4.24.15.2.1.3(1); 4.24.15.6(3)). Federal on-road inspections are paused during the fall 2026 relief, which runs through December 31, 2026.
What happens if my tank is clean?
The officer notes the plate and state and releases the driver (IRM 4.24.15.6.1(8)). The IRM says a Letter 3143 is issued for an inspection with no violation.
How long do I have to dispute a dyed diesel penalty?
30 days from receiving the penalty package, on Form 12009. After that you must pay the penalty and claim a refund on Form 843 (IRM 4.24.16.3(3) and (5)).
Can I get the penalty waived for reasonable cause?
No. The IRM says there is no reasonable cause exception to the IRC 6715IRC 6715Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII penalty (IRM 20.1.11.7.4(1)). Appeals can consider whether the fuel was dyed, what you knew and how many gallons were counted.
Will the IRS come back?
Yes. The IRM requires a follow-up inspection within 60 days of the penalty package, and a violation then is treated as a second penalty (IRM 4.24.16.2.5(4)).
Does a state dyed fuel ticket mean a federal penalty too?
Not automatically. The IRS weighs the state's sample and facts before assessing; if it does, the package includes Notice 1416 (IRM 4.24.16.2.1(1); 4.24.16.2.5(1)).